Legal Maneuvers: Ivanka Trump Seeks Trial Pause, Citing 'Undue Hardship' Amidst 'School Week' Testimony

image
Politics / Friday, 03 November 2023 14:12

"Legal Drama Unfolds: Ivanka Trump Seeks Trial Pause, Citing 'Undue Hardship' Over Mid-Week Testimony

In a twist of legal maneuvers, Ivanka Trump has petitioned a New York appeals court to halt the $250 million fraud trial involving her family and their business empire. The request for a pause in the entire trial, filed on Thursday, is rooted in Ivanka Trump's appeal of a judge's order mandating her testimony next week. The court filing contends that compelling her to testify would impose 'undue hardship,' particularly as it coincides with her appearance 'in the middle of a school week.'

The appeal faces opposition from New York Attorney General Letitia James, who deems it a 'drastic' and unfounded move that could disrupt the ongoing trial. Ivanka Trump's filing primarily seeks a temporary stay of the testimony order while she pursues an appeal. Her attorney filed a notice on Wednesday, signaling an appeal of every aspect of Manhattan Supreme Court Judge Arthur Engoron's order that denied her attempt to avoid the witness stand.

Scheduled to testify next Wednesday, Ivanka Trump follows in the footsteps of her father, former President Donald Trump, who has already given testimony. This comes after her brothers, Donald Trump Jr. and Eric Trump, testified earlier this week. The trio faces allegations in James' case, which accuses them of orchestrating a decade-long scheme to inflate Donald Trump Sr.'s net worth for financial gains, including tax benefits and favorable loan terms.

While Ivanka Trump was initially named as a co-defendant, she was removed from the case earlier this year on statute of limitations grounds by a New York appeals court. James' lawsuit details Ivanka's role as an executive vice president for development and acquisitions at the Trump Organization until early 2017, when she transitioned to a senior advisor role in her father's White House.

In Thursday's filing to the appeals court, Ivanka's attorney, Bennett Moskowitz, argues that she is 'beyond the jurisdiction' of Engoron's court. Moskowitz contends that the judge made 'multiple errors' when declining to quash subpoenas for Ivanka's testimony, emphasizing that she resides in Florida, not New York, raising questions about personal jurisdiction."

"Battle of Legal Arguments: Ivanka Trump's Plea for Trial Pause Sparks Heated Exchange

In the escalating legal drama surrounding Ivanka Trump's bid to halt the $250 million fraud trial, her attorney, Bennett Moskowitz, contends that subpoenas served to her were improperly executed. Highlighting Ivanka's residence in Florida with her three minor children, Moskowitz argues that compelling her to testify in New York during a school week, in a case she has been dismissed from, would inflict 'undue hardship.' This plea for a stay comes pending the outcome of her appeal.

New York Attorney General Letitia James swiftly responded, dismissing the argument of a lack of jurisdiction as 'utterly meritless.' James pointed out that Ivanka Trump still owns property in New York and continues to transact business in the state. She refutes the notion that witnesses with relevant, firsthand knowledge can only be called if they are primary actors in the case, asserting that Ivanka possesses crucial firsthand knowledge pivotal to the ongoing trial.

In a court filing, James emphasized that staying Ivanka's testimony could disrupt the trial, which has been in progress for almost a month, nearing the completion of the prosecution's case. The Attorney General contends that Ivanka's mere need to attend trial for a single day does not constitute a serious harm warranting emergency relief, and delaying her testimony could impede the fair and orderly resolution of the trial.

As the legal tussle unfolds, the courtroom battle intensifies, with each side presenting contrasting perspectives on jurisdiction, hardship, and the impact of delaying testimony in a case that has captured significant attention."

"As the legal saga surrounding Ivanka Trump's plea for a trial pause continues to unfold, the courtroom duel intensifies. In a bid to halt the $250 million fraud trial, Ivanka's attorney argued that improperly served subpoenas and the hardship of testifying in the middle of a school week in a case she's been dismissed from warranted a stay. However, New York Attorney General Letitia James swiftly dismissed these claims, asserting that they are 'utterly meritless.'

The battle revolves around the question of jurisdiction, with James highlighting Ivanka's continued connections to New York through property ownership and business transactions. James contends that delaying Ivanka's testimony, despite her being dismissed as a co-defendant, could significantly disrupt the ongoing trial, which has been in progress for almost a month.

The Attorney General emphasizes that Ivanka possesses firsthand knowledge crucial to the trial, and the mere need for her to attend for a single day does not constitute a serious harm warranting emergency relief. As both sides present contrasting perspectives on the impact of delaying testimony, the courtroom drama enters a critical phase, with the fair and orderly resolution of the trial hanging in the balance."